Student Temptations

The manifold temptations to which the student is subjected, the battle for his soul indeed, is the subject of an engraving signed with Jacob von der Heyden’s monogram and published in the 2nd edition of the Pugillus orSpeculum Cornelianum (Strasbourg, 1618). It shows the student at his desk, head in hand, with God the father in a cloud above him and a yawning hell-mouth beneath him. To his right he is approached by an angel and a skeletal Death holding hour-glass and dart, while to his left a bare-breasted (Venetian-style) courtesan and the Devil approach. I know of 5 painted versions of this scene in the album corpus, none of them dated ante 1618, the von Nostitz example being a very close copy of the print, the Gastel and Rosenberg (1615×23) examples being vertical in format, and another on a leaf that has been torn in half, leaving only the Devil and a (heavenly) image of Conscience visible – it is possible the page was censored thus on account of the unusually alluring nature of the courtesan.[i]

Frans Rosenberg  Copenhagen;

Gastel  Uppsala f.98r.;

Thielemann Regenstorff (after 1608)  Warnecke coll 1911 sale cat., no.91;

Kumasch von Machovic Prag, ANM B. c.1166 f. 54r.

Balthasar von Nostitz  Henrici auction cat. 11th June 1925, Nr. 111, & pl.VI, https://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/henrici1925_06_11


[i]  Frans Rosenberg  Copenhagen; Gastel  Uppsala f.98r.; Thielemann Regenstorff (after 1608)  Warnecke coll 1911 sale cat., no.91; Kumasch von Machovic Prag, ANM B. c.1166 f. 54r.; Balthasar von Nostitz  Henrici auction cat. 11th June 1925, Nr. 111, & pl.VI, https://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/henrici1925_06_11

Miniatures painted in several students’ alba amicorum copy a plate published in the Speculum Cornelianum (Strasbourg 1618), but the ‘student’ merely continues the ‘everyman’ of earlier representations, and the captioning Spruch goes back at least as far as Bebel’s Proverbia Germanica (1508): Noli peccare/ Deus videt/ Angelus adstat/ Conscientia mordet/ Mors minatur/ Diabolus accusat/ Inferi cruciant [Sin not! / God sees/ the Angel stands by/ Conscience gnaws/ Death threatens/ the Devil accuses/ Hell torments]

from the Speculum Cornelianum /2nd ed. of the Pugillus facetiarum — both print-books — in so far as they are not one and the same! — issued in Strasburg in 1618.

from the album of Balthasar von Nostitz (dated entries begin in 1608). Henrici auction cat. 11th June 1925, Nr. 111, & pl.VI — here via https://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/henrici1925_06_11. though this is a very close copy of the print, I note that the young Venetian courtesan’s bare breasts have been decently covered here! See the ‘censored’ image below

from the Frans Rosenberg album, adjacent page dated 1615. Copenhagen, Det Kongelige Bibliotek, Signatur
NKS 2090 h, 4°
from the Gastel album, Uppsala …… f.98r., adjacent page dated 1597.

from the Thielemann Regenstorff album, ante 1625, this scanned from the 1911 Warnecke sale cat. Now in the Focke Museum, Bremen..
perhaps censored on account of the young temptress ? cf. my remarks re the Balthasar von Nostitz image above.

student temptations VandA painted glass pane. 9060-1863 Winterthur, Switzerland, dated 1670

[what art historians do!]

A different version:

engraved by Isaac Brun after Boetius Abraham Bolswert; c.1627 is suggested by the Friedrich-Alexander Universitat’s Graphische Sammlung in whose collection it is

Origins of the composition; earlier versions

 From Wilhelm Werner von Zimmern’s “Verganglichkeitsbuch”, c.1540. Stuttgart, WLB, cod. don. A.III.54, f.131r.

slightly later version of previous; the 1565 copy of Wilhelm Werner von Zimmern’s “Verganglichkeitsbuch”, Stuttgart, WLB, cod. don. 123

Final illustration in Adam Walasser’s Kunst wol zusterben (Dilingen, 1569) via MDZ – a reference I owe to the great Francis Douce! This is the first time Conscience appears — indeed, the earliest I have found the composition with the ‘traditional’ speeches

detail (central subject) of Scheibenriss dated 1583 attributed to Swiss artist Christoph Murer. Karlsruhe, SKKK

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *